Very happy to introduce Manash Bhattacharjee. Manash is a doctorate in Political Theory from JNU and is presently as he puts it “just writing.” This is a response to ‘The Left and its Intellectual Detractors’ by Prabhat Patnaik. Read here.
The Party is Not Always Right- Manash Bhattacharjee
Prabhat Patnaik is upset about the “heat generated†over Nandigram in “intellectual circlesâ€. But he doesn’t state how the heat was directly proportional to the heat generated by the West Bengal Government over the lives of people in Nandigram. Patnaik is critically interested in only one side of the heat. Wonder why no heat was generated in him about the ruthless events in Nandigram. Maybe years of teaching have taken their toll. Or does belonging to the Party numb one’s senses more than anything else?
For Patnaik, the idea of the left intellectual seems to be of one who is first and foremost a thinking tool of and for the Party. Even Sartre with his idea of the “committed intellectual†would have shuddered at such a sterile expectation of the left intellectual. Patnaik can however be excused for falling short of Sartrean definitions because he doesn’t seem to have either the guts or the power to live up to them. But he can’t be excused, even within his modest intellect, for hiding the truth under the Party’s carpet of lies and go into the offensive against those who showed infinitely more courage than him to tear off the Party’s façade regarding Nandigram.







Recent Comments